Strange But True: How Being Replaceable Makes Your Community Bank Worth Millions More
Your most important job as a bank CEO might surprise you:
Make yourself replaceable.
Sounds backward, right?
But this surprising truth is key to making your bank worth more.
Why Your Bank Needs to Work Without You
Let me be straight with you:
If your bank can't run smoothly without you, buyers won't pay as much for it.
Don't get me wrong.
You have special skills as a leader, motivator and decision-maker.
Your guidance has helped your bank succeed.
No one can do exactly what you do.
But early in my banking career, I learned something important:
When selling any business, buyers want to see a team that can run things well when you're not there.
Your bank needs to keep making money without you.
This matters whether you plan to sell or not.
The Task Trap That Catches Most CEOs
Your job as a leader isn't about checking items off your to-do list.
Banking creates endless tasks from paperwork to business growth.
As CEO, it's time to think about how you spend your day.
Your real job isn't doing daily tasks—it's building a bank that doesn't need you for everyday operations.
The simple rule is:
Work ON the business, not IN it.
Systems, processes, and leadership create lasting value.
Your people are the key to building these systems and processes.
This is not just one person, but your whole team working together.
Your Main Job: Keeping the Culture
The CEO's most important role is "Keeper of the Culture."
Not because you're special, but because your values and beliefs guide the big decisions.
For a strong culture and happy employees, everyone needs to share similar values and beliefs.
This culture creates consistency.
And customers want consistency—not randomness or confusion.
Think about McDonald's.
They've sold billions of burgers without winning cooking awards.
Why?
Because a cheeseburger tastes the same in Seattle, Chicago, or Miami.
Consistency matters in:
- How accounts get opened
- How customers are welcomed
- How people are greeted by name
- How well customers are listened to
- How quickly phones are answered
- How problems get fixed
- How professionally employees dress
It includes bankers visiting customers instead of making them come to you. It covers everything from neat landscaping to clean parking lots.
Every detail shows your consistency.
All of it matters.
What Buyers Really Look For
Here's a tough truth:
Your buyer doesn't care about your culture.
Let that sink in.
Yes, your culture matters to your current success.
It's why customers love you.
But the buyer has their own CEO and their own culture.
While it's good to explain your culture in first meetings, don't expect it to survive after the sale.
Unless it's a rare case, it shouldn't.
It's possible both CEOs might share the same values—but that rarely happens.
What buyers really want is a bank with:
- Strong systems
- Clear processes
- Tested procedures
- People who can keep making money
Steady, reliable earnings interest them most. Their future depends on those earnings.
Warning Signs That Lower Your Value
If you handle customer relationships daily or if work stops when you're not available, buyers will see this as a problem.
Buyers notice telling signs when meeting you:
- Do you often take calls to answer questions for your team?
- Is it hard to schedule time with you because you're always busy?
- Do your employees look to you for answers during buyer meetings?
These show that you ARE the business.
This might feel good for your ego, but it makes your bank worth much less.
You might still sell your bank, but you'll have less power in deals and fewer interested buyers.
Which Employees Buyers Care About Most
Buyers care most about people who work directly with customers:
- Relationship managers
- Tellers and branch staff
- Customer service teams
They also want senior leaders who can help make the transition smooth.
In today's market, most buyers want to keep as many employees as possible since they need to fill positions throughout their company.
However, pay differences between city and rural areas might affect their plans.
A country bank buying a city bank might be shocked by higher salaries, while a city bank might expand teams in rural areas to save on costs.
Balancing Current Success with Future Value
This creates a tricky balance:
- Your culture matters for your current success
- Your people are vital to delivering that culture
- Customers love your bank because of both
But to get the highest sale price, you need systems that work without you.
Your goal should be building a bank where:
- Employees can grow their careers
- Customers get better service and products
- Shareholders get maximum value
- Communities continue to benefit
Your Action Plan
1) Review Your Daily Work
- What tasks can you hand over to others?
- Who needs training to take on these tasks?
- Do you have training plans ready?
- When is your best time to sell (your "Golden Window")?
- Can your training plans be finished by then?
2) Check Your Current Team
- Are they getting the results you need?
- What changes have you put off that need to happen?
- Can these changes be made before your best-selling time?
3) Write Down Your Systems
- Are your main processes documented?
- Could someone follow your procedures without asking you?
- Have you tested how things work when you're away?
4) Build Backup for Key Roles
- Which positions need backup people?
- Who could take over key roles if needed?
- Have you created growth paths for promising team members?
Remember:
Building a bank that works well without you doesn't make you less important.
It shows how great your leadership really is.
What are you doing to make yourself replaceable—and your bank irreplaceable?
There are no shortcuts or hacks in building the confidence needed for major strategic decisions.
Just proven approaches centered around preparation:
This approach will:
- Inform your strategic planning
- Guide your resource allocation
- Clarify your priorities
- Define your value proposition
This is how savvy bank leaders operate.
They build valuable institutions through preparation, allowing them to choose the optimal path forward on their own timeline – whether that's continued independence or a strategic transaction.
I’ll see you next week.
If you would like access to all prior newsletters - click here.
Not a subscriber? The newsletter is free - click here to become one now!
