Community Bank CEOs: Are your Board Members About to Kill Your Deal?
Picture this:
You're six months into a confidential bank sale.
Multiple buyers are interested.
Terms look great.
Then your phone rings.
"I heard you might be selling," says a competitor.
"We're hiring if any of your people want new opportunities."
Your heart sinks.
Word is out.
Your deal is about to fall apart.
Here's how to prevent this nightmare—and why one simple agreement can save your sale.
The Leak That Kills Deals
Any hint that your bank might be for sale creates instant problems:
Share value drops immediately.
Competitors call your employees.
Customers worry about the bank's future.
Most bank sale leaks trace back to the same source.
A board member having what they thought was a casual conversation.
Coffee with a trusted friend.
A comment to their spouse "in confidence."
Casual talk with a business partner.
Once word gets out, the damage is done.
Why Good Intentions Aren't Enough
Your board already has a duty to keep information secret.
They know this.
They take it seriously.
But these duties feel unclear.
When there's no formal reminder, people get comfortable.
They let their guard down.
"It's just my spouse," they think.
"This friend has kept secrets before."
That's exactly when leaks happen.
The Simple Solution That Changes Everything
During our bank sale, we implemented "Insider Agreements."
Every board member and deal team member signed a formal confidentiality agreement before getting any information about our potential sale.
Was this legally necessary?
Probably not.
They already had confidentiality duties.
But it changed everything.
Why Formal Agreements Work
When people sign documents, something psychological happens.
Responsibility becomes real.
Suddenly, every conversation gets filtered:
- "Should I mention this to my spouse?"
- "Can I trust this friend?"
- "What if this gets back to the wrong person?"
The formal agreement makes people think twice before they have a conversation that could give away secrets.
How We Implemented This
Our process was simple:
Every person signed before getting information. No exceptions.
New team members signed immediately. As our deal team grew, each new person signed before their first meeting.
Management signed hours before the announcement. Even our management team signed just hours before we went public.
Legal counsel supported the approach. Our experienced lawyers strongly recommended formal agreements.
The result?
Zero leaks throughout our entire process.
The Stakes Are Too High
Here's what happens when information leaks:
Competitors attack immediately.
They call your employees with job offers.
They contact customers suggesting your bank is unstable.
Buyer confidence drops.
Deal value suffers.
The process gets complicated.
You cannot afford even one word to leak.
Working with Your Board
When introducing Insider Agreements, frame it properly:
"These agreements aren't about trust. They're about protecting everyone and maximizing shareholder value. Leaks destroy deals."
Most boards understand immediately.
They want to protect shareholders.
Formal agreements help them do that.
Results That Speak for Themselves
Our formal approach delivered:
- Zero leaks throughout the entire process
- Complete confidentiality from start to finish
- No employee or customer disruption
- Successful sale that maximized shareholder value
Could we have succeeded without formal agreements?
Maybe.
But why take that risk?
Your Action Plan
1) Talk to legal counsel - Discuss formal confidentiality agreements
2) Prepare your board - Explain formal agreements are coming
3) Plan for expansion - Decide how you'll handle new team members
4) Coordinate with advisors - Make sure everyone understands your approach
Remember:
A leak could be disastrous.
Formal agreements prevent problems before they start.
P.S. I'm not a lawyer, an accountant, or an investment banker. Just a banker who has been in your shoes.
There are no shortcuts or hacks in building the confidence needed for major strategic decisions.
Just proven approaches centered around preparation:
This approach will:
- Inform your strategic planning
- Guide your resource allocation
- Clarify your priorities
- Define your value proposition
This is how savvy bank leaders operate.
They build valuable institutions through preparation, allowing them to choose the optimal path forward on their own timeline – whether that's continued independence or a strategic transaction.
I’ll see you next week.
If you would like access to all prior newsletters - click here.
Not a subscriber? The newsletter is free - click here to become one now!
