Community Bank CEOs: Why Most Bank Acquisitions Lose Their Best Employees in Year One
This article is primarily for bank buyers.
But if you're a seller, read it anyway.
Understanding the buyer's perspective helps you prepare your team.
This guidance is meant to help your acquisition succeed.
Read it in that spirit.
If you get this right, you'll distinguish yourself in your employees' eyes.
That will translate directly to how they treat your customers.
The Employee Meeting Blitz You Must Do
Since the announcement, you've had some employee interaction.
Maybe town halls.
Maybe department meetings.
Maybe informal conversations.
That's not enough.
It's time for the employee meeting blitz.
This means sitting down face-to-face with each employee individually.
Not group meetings.
Not department check-ins.
One-on-one conversations.
The goal:
Make absolutely certain employees know their role isn't being disrupted by the change.
"Wait," you're thinking.
"Didn't we just do this 90 days ago?"
Yes.
Do it again.
There's no such thing as over-communicating during an acquisition.
Your Competition Is Actively Recruiting Right Now
While you've been focused on closing the deal, competitors have been calling your newly acquired employees non-stop.
They're not being subtle about it either.
LinkedIn messages.
Phone calls.
Text messages.
Lunch invitations.
Post-closing, they'll ramp up even harder.
They know this is prime recruiting season.
Employees are uncertain.
Change creates anxiety.
People are vulnerable to outside offers.
You have to counter this aggressively.
What Employees Actually Want
Here's what most acquirers get wrong:
Employees don't want your logo swag.
They don't care about your branded water bottles or your new company t-shirts.
They also don't want to hear generic corporate speak about who you are.
"We care about our employees."
"People are our most important asset."
"We value diversity and inclusion."
Empty platitudes.
Just noise.
Every company says this stuff.
At least your competition's recruiting pitch is equally meaningless:
"We're reaching out to see if you're interested in an exploratory call to see if there are potential synergies."
Corporate buzzword bingo.
It's filler that replaces the real work of actually describing the role they're recruiting for.
What employees actually want is straightforward:
They want to not be distracted.
Their employer shouldn't become a constant source of stress and disruption.
They have work to do.
They want their investment protected.
They've invested years building their career.
They want to know that time and effort still matters.
They want smooth transitions.
No abrupt role changes.
No surprise compensation adjustments.
No benefit disruptions without time to adapt.
They want to feel valued.
They want the "new guys" to know who they are, respect their contributions, and genuinely want them on the team.
If you don't demonstrate these things through action, employees will fill in the blanks.
And they'll assume the worst.
Actions Speak Louder Than Corporate Speak
Employees are exhausted from hearing what companies claim to be.
They want to see what companies actually do.
Showing up for one-on-one meetings is action.
It proves you care enough to invest time in understanding each person.
Following through on commitments is action.
Doing what you say you'll do.
Honoring promises made during due diligence.
Providing clear information about roles, compensation, and expectations is action.
No vague promises.
No "we'll figure it out later."
Concrete details.
This is how you retain talent during acquisitions.
The Questions Every Employee Needs Answered
In your one-on-one meetings, employees need clarity on specific questions:
"What happens to my role?"
Be specific.
Is it staying the same?
Expanding?
Changing?
If you don't know yet, say so and give them a timeline for when you will know.
"What happens to my compensation?"
Don't dance around this.
They need to know if their pay changes.
When it changes.
How it changes.
"What happens to my benefits?"
Health insurance.
Retirement contributions.
PTO policies.
They need specifics, not promises to "work it out."
"Who do I report to?"
Organizational structure matters.
If it's unclear, that creates anxiety.
"How does my career path change?"
Are there new opportunities?
Different progression paths?
What does success look like now?
"What do you need from me?"
Give them clear expectations.
What are their priorities?
What should they focus on?
What does excellent performance look like going forward?
Don't avoid tough questions.
If the answer is "I don't know yet," that's okay.
Just give them a timeline for when you'll have answers.
Uncertainty is manageable if there's a plan to resolve it.
Uncertainty without a plan creates panic.
The Temptation to Turn Inward
After closing, there's a natural urge to focus internally.
You're integrating systems.
Learning new processes.
Meeting new colleagues.
Navigating organizational politics.
It's easy to get consumed by your own adjustment and forget about the employees you just acquired.
Don't let this happen.
You made a major investment.
You're counting on the future earnings power of this bank to pay for the acquisition and contribute to even higher earnings for the combined organization.
The work you put in during the year following closing—if done properly—will pay dividends repeatedly into the future.
Resist the temptation to think, "Well, that's done. What's next?"
You have too much riding on this to treat it casually.
The First Year Is Critical
The first 12 months after closing determine whether your acquisition succeeds or fails.
If you lose key employees during this period, you've damaged the asset you just paid millions to acquire.
If talented people leave, customers follow.
Knowledge walks out the door.
Institutional memory disappears.
Training costs spike as you scramble to replace them.
The employee retention work you do now protects your investment.
Think about it this way:
You paid a premium for this bank.
That premium was based partly on the quality of the team.
If that team leaves, you overpaid.
Prioritize Your One-on-One Meetings
You can't meet with everyone the first week.
Prioritize strategically.
Start with employees who have the most impact on the bank's success.
Your management succession plan should guide this.
Tier 1: Key leaders and decision makers
These are the people who run critical functions.
Revenue generators.
Credit officers.
Operations leaders.
Meet with them immediately.
Tier 2: High performers and specialized talent
People with unique skills or deep relationships.
Technology specialists.
Experienced lenders.
Trusted advisors to major customers.
Tier 3: Everyone else
Yes, everyone.
Every employee deserves a conversation.
Even if it takes several weeks to get through everyone, commit to doing it.
What Buyers Need to Know About Each Employee
Before those one-on-one meetings, do your homework.
For each employee, understand:
How would you present this person to someone else?
What makes them valuable?
What's their contribution?
What does the buyer (you) need to know about them?
Tenure? Performance history?
Customer relationships?
Technical expertise?
Career ambitions?
What concerns might they have?
Family situation that affects relocation decisions?
Health issues that make benefits critical?
Career goals that might not fit the new structure?
This preparation makes the conversation productive rather than generic.
If You're a Seller, Prepare Your Team
If you're selling, help the buyer succeed by preparing your team.
Create detailed profiles of key employees.
Not just resumes—actual insights into what makes them valuable and what they need to stay.
Identify which employees are flight risks.
Who's already being recruited?
Who's unhappy?
Who's on the fence?
Be honest with the buyer about retention challenges.
Surprises after closing damage trust and hurt the team.
Your reputation matters.
Future opportunities depend on how well this transition goes.
The Long-Term Payoff
Getting employee retention right in the first year pays off for years.
Retained employees become advocates.
They tell customers to stay.
They recruit their networks to join.
They become champions of the combined organization.
Lost employees become critics.
They warn others away.
They speak negatively about the acquisition.
They encourage customers to leave.
The difference in outcomes is enormous.
And it all comes down to how you treat people in those critical first 12 months after closing.
The Bottom Line
After closing, conduct individual one-on-one meetings with every acquired employee, starting with the most critical roles. Skip the corporate platitudes and logo swag—employees need clear answers about their specific role, compensation, benefits, reporting structure, and career path. Your competitors are actively recruiting these employees, so actions matter more than words. The work you invest in employee retention during the first year determines whether your acquisition succeeds or fails.
P.S. I'm not a lawyer, an accountant, or an investment banker. Just a former bank CEO who has been in your shoes.
There are zero hacks or tricks in this newsletter. Just proven tactics that help you choose the right path for your bank.
Your path will:
- Inform your strategic plan.
- Guide your annual business plan and budget.
- Clarify priorities.
- Define your message so it can be communicated with confidence.
This is how savvy bankers navigate.
They build smart and valuable banks and choose the best time to sell on a timeline of their own choosing – serving the needs of the shareholders and the board.
I hope you found this short lesson helpful.
What are your thoughts?
I’ll see you next week.
If you would like access to all prior newsletters - click here.
Not a subscriber? The newsletter is free - click here to become one now!
